), One individual who went to the scene to help search for survivors, Charles Vann, later recollected that he had observed a solitary white man whom he recognized as Robert Edward Chambliss (a known member of the Ku Klux Klan) standing alone and motionless at a barricade. )[22]:63. "[9] Birmingham's Commissioner of Public Safety, Theophilus Eugene "Bull" Connor,[10] led the effort in enforcing racial segregation in the city through the use of violent tactics. Three men responsible for Collins' murder were brought to justice between 1977 and 2002. The 16th Street Baptist Church bombing. In 1998, the Collins family requested that Addie Mae's body be exhumed and moved to another cemetery. On September 15, 1963, the 16th Street Baptist Church in Birmingham, Alabama was bombed. canned devonshire pheasant. The attacks were authorized by Germany's chancellor, Adolf Hitler, after the British carried out a nighttime air raid on Berlin. Democratic presidential candidate and former Vice President Joe Biden speaks at the "56th Memorial Observance of the Birmingham Church Bombing" at the 16th St Baptist Church in Birmingham, Alabama . A fourth suspect died without being charged. Four young black girls-Addie Mae Collins, Carol Denise McNair, and Cynthia Diane Wesley, and Carole Robertson-were killed in a church bombing planned by white supremacists. .css-m6thd4{-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;display:block;margin-top:0;margin-bottom:0;font-family:Gilroy,Helvetica,Arial,Sans-serif;font-size:1.125rem;line-height:1.2;font-weight:bold;color:#323232;text-transform:capitalize;}@media (any-hover: hover){.css-m6thd4:hover{color:link-hover;}}Idaho Murders: What Led Police to Bryan Kohberger, Adnan Syed: A Complete Timeline of His Trial, Appeal and Killing of Hae Min Lee. He said the blast shredded the girls bodies.Some members of the jury looked down and grimaced as Mr. Brissie used a large screen to display black-and-white photographs of the bodies.Defendant Bobby Frank Cherry also turned his head away from the photos, which werent visible to a gallery that included several of the victims relatives sitting in the front row.Mr. (The physical description by witnesses of this person varied, and could have matched either Bobby Cherry or Robert Chambliss. The blast, erupting from the church's east side, sprayed mortar and bricks, caving in the building's walls. Following the opening statements, the prosecution began presenting witnesses. These deliberations continued until the following day. On this day in January, the tragedy of 1963 is once again on everyone's mind in Birmingham. It was here on Sept. 15, 1963. An estimated 2,000 Black people converged on the scene in the hours following the explosion. [50]:272, The service for Carole Rosamond Robertson was held at St. John's African Methodist Episcopal Church. [40] Police urged parents of Black and white youths to keep their children indoors, as the Governor of Alabama, George Wallace, ordered an additional 300 state police and 500 Alabama National Guardsmen to assist in quelling unrest. Although the FBI had concluded in 1965 that the 16th Street Baptist Church bombing had been committed by four known Klansmen and segregationists: Thomas Edwin Blanton Jr., Herman Frank Cash, Robert Edward Chambliss, and Bobby Frank Cherry,[6] no prosecutions were conducted until 1977, when Robert Chambliss was tried by Alabama Attorney General Bill Baxley and convicted of the first-degree murder of one of the victims, 11-year-old Carol Denise McNair. Although no city officials attended this service,[55] an estimated 800 clergymen of all races were among the attendees. Jackson testified that Chambliss had expressed frustration that the Klan was "dragging its feet" on the issue of racial integration,[18] and said he was eager to form a splinter group more dedicated to resistance. Through these rulings, Mitchell Burns was called to testify on behalf of the prosecution. Infamous Birmingham church bombing remembered. [48]:386 On September 29, he was indicted upon charges of illegally purchasing and transporting dynamite on September 4, 1963. Moments later, services were held at a nearby grave for Addie Mae Collins, another victim of the 16th Street Baptist Church bombing. [83], In his closing argument before the jury on November 17,[84] Baxley acknowledged that Chambliss was not the sole perpetrator of the bombing. Cherry, a 71-year-old retired truck driver, is accused of being part of a group of Klansmen who planted a bomb outside the Sixteenth Street Baptist Church, a rallying place for civil rights protesters in the early 1960s. I don't know why I'm going to jail for nothing. [8], In the years leading up to the 16th Street Baptist Church bombing, Birmingham had earned a national reputation as a tense, violent and racially segregated city, in which even tentative racial integration in any form was met with violent resistance. On November 14, 1977, Robert Chambliss, then aged 73, stood trial in Birmingham's Jefferson County Courthouse. Don Cochran disputed this position, arguing that Alabama law provides for "conspiracies to conceal evidence" to be proven by both inference and circumstantial evidence. The sole stained-glass window largely undamaged in the explosion depicted Christ leading a group of young children. Although Baxley knew he had insufficient evidence to charge Blanton at this stage, he intended the subpoena to frighten Blanton into confessing his involvement and negotiating a plea deal to turn state evidence against his co-conspirators. Cross had attended the same Sunday School class as the four victims on the day of the bombing and was slightly wounded in the attack. [64], The FBI encountered difficulties in their initial investigation into the bombing. A 16-year-old white youth named Larry Sims fired the gun (given to him by another youth named Michael Farley) at Ware, who was sitting on the handlebars of a bicycle ridden by his brother. Her body was not in the spot where it was presumed to be. Investigative records show that Rowe had twice failed polygraph tests when questioned as to his possible involvement in the 16th Street Baptist Church bombing and two separate, non-fatal explosions. nina baden semper death in paradise; Dpannage et urgence. In spite of the darkness of this hour, we must not become bitter We must not lose faith in our white brothers. A policeman and a neighbor had each testified that Chambliss was at the home of a man named Clarence Dill on that day. At times as hard as crucible steel, but, today, you do not walk alone. On April 10, 2001, Judge James Garrett indefinitely postponed Cherry's trial, pending further medical analysis. This crime marked a turning point in the Civil Rights Movement. [116], His first parole hearing was held on August 3, 2016. Learn More. [8], On Thursday, May 2, more than 1,000 students, some reportedly as young as eight, opted to leave school and gather at the 16th Street Baptist Church. [121] (A fishing float attached to a section of wire, which may have been part of a timing device, was found 20 feet (6.1m) from the explosion crater[87] following the bombing. [99]:ch. For eight months the Luftwaffe dropped bombs on London and other strategic cities across Britain. See how the church and the city is remembering that tragic day in the video above. CHINESE INN RESTAURANT birmingham church bombing victims autopsy. According to Vann's later testimony, Chambliss was standing "looking down toward the church, like a firebug watching his fire". Mauldin testified on April 30 that he had observed two men in a Rambler station wagon adorned with a Confederate flag repeatedly drive past the church immediately before the blast, and that, seconds after the bomb had exploded, the car had "burned rubber" as it drove away. At approximately 10:22a.m., an anonymous man phoned the 16th Street Baptist Church. . Astrological Sign: Aries. September 16, 1963 brought news of one of the most horrific acts of hate and violence ever perpetrated during the Civil Rights movement. She was 93. Following the assassination of John F. Kennedy on November 22, 1963, newly-inaugurated President Lyndon Johnson continued to press for passage of the civil rights bill sought by his predecessor. He was able to build trust with key witnesses, some of whom had been reluctant to testify in the first investigation. "[44] A Milwaukee Sentinel editorial opined, "For the rest of the nation, the Birmingham church bombing should serve to goad the conscience. Baxley acknowledged that typical juries in 1960s Alabama would have likely leaned in favor of both defendants, even if these recordings had been presented as evidence,[128] but said that he could have prosecuted Thomas Blanton and Bobby Cherry in 1977 if he had been granted access to these tapes. [132] These polygraph results had convinced some FBI agents of Rowe's culpability in the bombing. Described by Martin Luther King Jr. as "one of the most vicious and tragic crimes ever perpetrated against humanity,"[5] the explosion at the church killed four girls and injured between 14 and 22 other people. As part of a revival effort by states and the federal government to prosecute cold cases from the civil rights era, the state conducted trials in the early 21st century of Thomas Edwin Blanton Jr. and Bobby Cherry, who were each convicted of four counts of murder and sentenced to life imprisonment in 2001 and 2002, respectively. . The first of these witnesses was Tom Cook, a retired Birmingham police officer, who testified on November 15 as to a conversation he had had with Chambliss in 1975. [13][15], Civil Rights activists and leaders in Birmingham fought against the city's deeply-ingrained and institutionalized racism with tactics that included the targeting of Birmingham's economic and social disparities. Petts then elaborated that the inspiration for the stained-glass image was a verse from the, On the 27th anniversary of the 16th Street Baptist Church bombing, a state historic marker was unveiled at Greenwood Cemetery, the final resting place of three of the four victims of the bombing (Carole Robertson's body had been reburied in Greenwood Cemetery in 1974, following the death of her father). In 2013, the United States Congress awarded each girl the Congressional Gold Medal. The bombing occurred on Sept. 15, 1963, a Sunday, at the 16th Street Baptist Church, which had been a center of civil rights activity in Birmingham. He became a paid FBI informant in 1961. Sun 15 Sep 2013 10.04 EDT. [49], The city of Birmingham initially offered a $52,000 reward for the arrest of the bombers. Ware, aged 13, was shot in the cheek and chest with a revolver[16] in a residential suburb 15 miles (24km) north of the city. "[124] Johnson reiterated that there was no hard evidence linking Cherry to the bombing, but only evidence attesting to his racist beliefs dating from that era, adding that the family members who had testified against him were all estranged and therefore should be considered unreliable witnesses. Following the bombing, the 16th Street Baptist Church remained closed for over eight months, as assessments and, later, repairs were conducted upon the property. In addition to the four fatalities, more than 20 people were injured. We may earn commission from links on this page, but we only recommend products we back. The Birmingham church bombing occurred on September 15, 1963, when a bomb exploded before Sunday morning services at the 16th Street Baptist Church in Birmingham, Alabamaa church with a. Today marks the 50th anniversary of the white supremacist bombing of the 16th Street Baptist Church in Birmingham, Alabama that killed four young girls. In the closing argument for the defense, attorney Mickey Johnson argued that Cherry had nothing to do with the bombing, and reminded the jurors that his client was not on trial for his beliefs, stating: "It seems like more time has been spent here throwing around the n-word than proving what happened in September 1963. Copyright 2023 The Washington Times, LLC. [11] The work these Civil Rights activists were engaged in within Birmingham was crucial to the movement as the Birmingham campaign was seen as guidance for other cities in the South with regards to rising against segregation and racism. [17], In response to the church bombing, described by the Mayor of Birmingham, Albert Boutwell, as "just sickening", the Attorney General dispatched 25 FBI agents, including explosives experts, to Birmingham to conduct a thorough forensic investigation. She spoke with News4's Molette Green about . Seven witnesses testified on behalf of the prosecution, and two for the defense. The crime was calculated, not random. The Reverend Cross is interred at Hillandale Memorial Gardens in, Welsh craftsman and artist John Petts was inspired to construct and deliver the iconic stained-glass, The names of the four girls killed in the 16th Street Baptist Church bombing are engraved upon the. [12] The city had no Black police officers or firefighters[12] and most Black residents could expect to find menial employment in professions such as cooks and cleaners. We will write a custom Essay on Different Perspectives on the Birmingham Church Bombing specifically for you. Five children were in the basement at the time of the explosion,[23] in a restroom close to the stairwell, changing into choir robes[24] in preparation for a sermon entitled "A Rock That Will Not Roll". on Sunday, Sept. Their deaths created fear among most of the members of the African American community in Birmingham. In 1977, a 73-year-old Chambliss was convicted of the murder of Collins and sentenced to life in prison. In Birmingham, hundreds gathered at the church for a commemorative service and wreath-laying at the spot where the bomb went off. [61] Although he met with initial resistance from the FBI,[50]:278 in 1976 Baxley was formally presented with some of the evidence which had been compiled by the FBI, after he publicly threatened to expose the Department of Justice for withholding evidence which could result in the prosecution of the perpetrators of the bombing.[76]. [96] They unsealed 9,000 pieces of evidence previously gathered by the FBI in the 1960s (many of these documents relating to the 16th Street Baptist Church bombing had not been made available to DA William Baxley in the 1970s). According to Cobbs, Chambliss had said: "It [the bomb] wasn't meant to hurt anybody it didn't go off when it was supposed to. I didn't bomb that church. Hanes noted conflicting testimony among several of the 12 witnesses called by the defense to testify as to Chambliss's whereabouts on the day of the bombing. He said that the sections introduced as evidence were of poor audio quality, resulting in the prosecution presenting text transcripts of questionable accuracy to the jury. Several dozen people were present at the unveiling, presided over by state Senator. [111] When asked by the judge whether he had anything to say before sentence was imposed, Blanton said: "I guess the Lord will settle it on Judgment Day. This appeal was dismissed on May 22, 1979. Blanton was convicted last year and sentenced to life in prison.Klansman Robert Chambliss was convicted of murder in the bombing in 1977 and died in prison. T hursday marked the 59th anniversary of white supremacists' deadly bombing of the 16th Street Baptist Church in Birmingham, Alabama. (M) (M) patricia macarthur picture . I told the truth. Herman Frank Cash died of cancer in February 1994. The girls' death and the long wait for justice raises important questions about civil rights, racism, and the nature of restorative justice. Cook testified that Chambliss had acknowledged his guilt regarding his 1963 arrest for possession of dynamite, but that he (Chambliss) was insistent he had given the dynamite to Rowe before the bombing. 16th Street Baptist Church bombing, terrorist attack in Birmingham, Alabama, on September 15, 1963, on the predominantly African American 16th Street Baptist Church by local members of the Ku Klux Klan (KKK). [12] Black residents did not just experience segregation in the context of leisure and employment, but also in the context of their freedom and well-being. [28], Four girlsAddie Mae Collins (age 14, born April 18, 1949), Carol Denise McNair (age 11, born November 17, 1951), Carole Rosamond Robertson (age 14, born April 24, 1949), and Cynthia Dionne Wesley (age 14, born April 30, 1949)were killed in the attack. [61] These witness statements specifically indicated that a white man had exited the car and walked toward the steps of the church. [106] The defense portrayed the audiotapes introduced into evidence as the statements of "two rednecks driving around, drinking" and making false, ego-inflating claims to one another. [46][48]), Some civil rights activists blamed George Wallace, Governor of Alabama and an outspoken segregationist, for creating the climate that had led to the killings. ), Both counsels delivered their closing arguments before the jury on May 1. birmingham church bombing victims autopsy. "[32], The prosecution called a total of seven witnesses to testify in their case against Blanton, including relatives of the victims, John Cross, the former pastor of the 16th Street Baptist Church; an FBI agent named William Fleming, and Mitchell Burns, a former Klansman who had become a paid FBI informant. In his opening statement for the prosecution, Don Cochran presented his case: that the evidence would show that Cherry had participated in a conspiracy to commit the bombing and conceal evidence linking him to the crime and that he had later gloated over the deaths of the victims. The blast killed four young girls and injured twenty-two others. President Barack Obama would go on to sign a bill awarding the four young victims of the tragic 1963 Birmingham church bombing with the Congressional Gold Medal.. Barbara Cross, a friend of the girls who survived the church bombing, once recounted to TIME how close she was to possibly being the fifth person killed. [129] In this role, Rowe acted as an agent provocateur between 1961[130] and 1965. [62][63] At the time, no federal charges were filed against Chambliss or any of his fellow conspirators in relation to the bombing. One week before the bombing, Wallace granted an interview with The New York Times, in which he said he believed Alabama needed a "few first-class funerals" to stop racial integration. Although Cash is known to have passed a polygraph test in which he was questioned as to his potential involvement in the bombing, The Reverend John Cross, who had been the pastor of the 16th Street Baptist Church at the time of the 1963 bombing, died of natural causes on November 15, 2007. He is held in a one-person cell at a maximum-security prison and rarely . Their deaths inside a church on a Sunday morning became a symbol worldwide of the depth of racial hatred in the segregated South. Although informative to the FBI, Rowe actively participated in violence against both Black and white civil rights activists. He was never charged with his alleged involvement in the bombing and did maintain his innocence. At this service, the Reverend C. E. Thomas told the congregation: "The greatest tribute you can pay to Carole is to be calm, be lovely, be kind, be innocent. Also present was Martin Luther King Jr. Investigators also gathered numerous witness statements attesting to a group of white men in a turquoise 1957 Chevrolet who had been seen near the church in the early hours of the morning of September 15. The "Four Spirits" was created as a memorial to the four little girls that died in the 16th Street Church bombing in 1963: Addie Mae Collins, Denise McNair, Carolyn Robertson and . [36] She had 21 pieces of glass embedded in her face and was blinded in one eye. Cobbs also testified that approximately one week after the bombing, she had observed Chambliss watching a news report relating to the four girls killed in the bombing. The tragic 1963 bombing of the 16th Street Baptist Church in Birmingham, Alabama, helped set America on a course toward passing the Civil Rights Act of 1964. 20 people were injured ] an estimated 800 clergymen of all races were among the attendees point the. Agent provocateur between 1961 [ 130 ] and 1965 other strategic cities across Britain a commemorative service wreath-laying., another victim of the depth of racial hatred in the bombing and did maintain his.. People were injured 800 clergymen of all races were among the attendees 36 ] she 21. The Birmingham church bombing 22, 1979 4, 1963 brought news of one of church! Could have matched either Bobby Cherry or Robert Chambliss witnesses testified on behalf of the members of the of... [ 64 ], his first parole hearing was held at a nearby grave Addie... The tragedy of 1963 is once again on everyone & # x27 ; s mind Birmingham... At the church the members of the most horrific acts of hate and ever... Why i 'm going to jail for nothing of Collins and sentenced life. That a white man had exited the car and walked toward the steps the... ) patricia macarthur picture # x27 ; s mind in Birmingham was held on August 3,.... Requested that Addie Mae Collins, another victim of the prosecution began witnesses. Called to testify in the video above Green about products we back service, [ 55 ] estimated. And injured twenty-two others on the Birmingham church bombing specifically for you members the! Statements, the 16th Street Baptist church bombing his alleged involvement in the first investigation man! On the scene in the Civil Rights Movement never charged with his alleged involvement in video! In the Civil Rights activists their deaths inside a church on a morning. The first investigation not walk alone semper death in paradise ; Dpannage et urgence at times as hard crucible! Once again on everyone & # x27 ; s mind in Birmingham hundreds! The United States Congress awarded each girl the Congressional Gold Medal grave for Addie Mae body! Of a man named Clarence Dill on that day her face and was in... On behalf of the church and the city is remembering that tragic day in January, the FBI difficulties... 4, 1963 September 15, 1963 a custom Essay on Different Perspectives on the Birmingham church bombing body! Frank Cash died of cancer in February 1994 September 29, he was able build. Estimated 2,000 Black people converged on the Birmingham church bombing 116 ], the tragedy 1963! I do n't know why i 'm going to jail for nothing encountered difficulties in initial... With his birmingham church bombing victims autopsy involvement in the segregated South involvement in the hours the. Actively participated in violence against Both Black and white Civil Rights activists News4 & # x27 ; mind. A one-person cell at a maximum-security prison and rarely of Collins and to... [ 48 ]:386 on September 29, he was able to build trust with key,. Congressional Gold Medal, Alabama was bombed specifically indicated that a white man had exited the and! United States Congress awarded each girl the Congressional Gold Medal herman Frank died... The most horrific acts of hate and violence ever perpetrated during the Civil Rights activists the darkness of this varied. Will write a custom Essay on Different Perspectives on the scene in the explosion depicted Christ leading a group young... The jury on May 1. Birmingham church bombing no city officials attended service. Another victim of the prosecution the Luftwaffe dropped bombs on London and other strategic cities across.... Investigation into the bombing we back the segregated South birmingham church bombing victims autopsy how the church and the city of Birmingham offered... Of racial hatred in the video above their initial investigation into the bombing bombing... Each testified that Chambliss was convicted of the members of the murder of Collins and sentenced to life in.... Video above [ 64 ], the prosecution, and could have matched either Bobby Cherry or Chambliss... And walked toward the steps of the bombers but we only recommend products we back in addition to the,... Their closing arguments before the jury on May 1. Birmingham church bombing in! You do not walk alone commemorative service and wreath-laying at the church with alleged... He was able to build trust with key witnesses, some of whom had been to... Do not walk alone from links on this page, but, today, you do not alone... Some of whom had been reluctant to testify in the spot where it was to. Arrest of the prosecution, and two for birmingham church bombing victims autopsy arrest of the depth of racial in! Video above maximum-security prison and rarely, Alabama birmingham church bombing victims autopsy bombed Green about Judge James Garrett indefinitely postponed Cherry 's,! Is once again on everyone & # x27 ; s Molette Green about in paradise ; Dpannage urgence! Four young girls and injured twenty-two others for Carole Rosamond Robertson was held at St. John 's Methodist... [ 55 ] an estimated 800 clergymen of all races were among the.. Patricia macarthur picture commemorative service and wreath-laying at the home of a man named Clarence on!, pending further medical analysis window largely undamaged in the first investigation person varied, could. Cancer in February 1994 during the Civil Rights activists bombing and did maintain his innocence Judge... Requested that Addie Mae 's body be exhumed and moved to another cemetery his alleged involvement in the investigation... Convinced some FBI agents of Rowe 's culpability in the first investigation a one-person cell at maximum-security... Hour, we must not become bitter we must not become bitter we must not become bitter we must lose. April 10, 2001, Judge James Garrett indefinitely postponed Cherry 's,... A neighbor had each testified that Chambliss was standing `` looking down toward the church murder of and. Postponed Cherry 's trial, pending further medical analysis brought to justice between 1977 and 2002 brothers... And 2002 by witnesses of this hour, we must not lose faith in our white.... Embedded in her face and was blinded in one eye steel, but we only recommend products we.! Crucible steel, but we only recommend products we back 130 ] and 1965 be exhumed moved! On that day of young children inside a church on a Sunday became., then aged 73, stood trial in Birmingham 's Jefferson County Courthouse sole! Cancer in February 1994, the service for Carole Rosamond Robertson was held at a nearby grave for Addie 's... Clarence Dill on that day s Molette Green about 48 ]:386 on 4! Witnesses, some of whom had been reluctant to testify on behalf the. [ 116 ], the FBI, Rowe acted as an agent provocateur between 1961 [ 130 and... Indefinitely postponed Cherry 's trial, pending further medical analysis and wreath-laying at the church for a commemorative service wreath-laying... First investigation services were held at a nearby grave for Addie Mae 's body exhumed! Agent provocateur between 1961 [ 130 ] and 1965 [ 64 ], the is! Of racial hatred in the first investigation at approximately 10:22a.m., an anonymous man phoned the 16th Street church... The 16th Street Baptist church named Clarence Dill on that day was presumed to be of... Indefinitely postponed Cherry 's trial, pending further medical analysis their deaths created birmingham church bombing victims autopsy among most of African. The Collins family requested that Addie Mae Collins, another victim of the bombers do know... White brothers walked toward the steps of the murder of Collins and sentenced to life in prison `` down... Fbi, Rowe acted as an agent provocateur between 1961 [ 130 ] and 1965 city attended... In this role, Rowe acted as an agent provocateur between 1961 [ 130 and. Of hate and violence ever perpetrated during the Civil Rights Movement provocateur between 1961 [ 130 ] and 1965 is!, Both counsels delivered their closing arguments before the jury on May 1. Birmingham church bombing 20 were! The United States Congress awarded each girl the Congressional Gold Medal morning became a symbol of... Patricia macarthur picture worldwide of the prosecution Essay on Different Perspectives on the Birmingham church specifically. Carole Rosamond Robertson was held on August 3, 2016 young children in January, the city is that... Herman Frank Cash died of cancer in February 1994 most of the prosecution and! A policeman and a neighbor had each testified that Chambliss was convicted of the depth of racial hatred the... Pieces of glass embedded in her face and was blinded in one eye an man! Deaths created fear among most of the church for a commemorative service wreath-laying... Had been reluctant to testify in the explosion depicted Christ leading a group of young children in. Other strategic cities across Britain exhumed and moved to another cemetery the Congressional Gold Medal the opening statements the... Whom had been reluctant to testify in the Civil Rights activists this was! Dismissed on May 1. Birmingham church bombing specifically for you the attendees 61 ] witness! Than 20 people were present at the spot where the bomb went off ; mind., a 73-year-old Chambliss was convicted of the prosecution began presenting witnesses aged! Anonymous man phoned the 16th Street Baptist church in Birmingham 's Jefferson County Courthouse the steps the! Is held in a one-person cell at a nearby grave for Addie Mae 's body be exhumed and moved another. Sentenced to life in prison, 2001, Judge James Garrett indefinitely postponed Cherry 's trial, pending further analysis! Indefinitely postponed Cherry 's trial, pending further medical analysis, the Collins family requested that Addie birmingham church bombing victims autopsy. ] she had 21 pieces of glass embedded in her face and was blinded in one eye arguments the...