It wasn't until then that Carol noticed Lizzie was playing with the zombies and treated them like people. Hershel wins, sneaking out to get elderberries a natural flu remedy, he notes. They died from the flu. Were you surprised that Carol burned Karen and David? Sam and Ana encounter Rick Grimes, who kills a walker outside of a room in the house which they are trapped in. Why did Carol kill? What she did: Threatened to hose off Daryl. Sounds Off, 'Walking Dead' Dissection: Robert Kirkman Talks Carol's Shocking Confession, 'The Walking Dead' Renewed for Fifth Season, Gimple Staying Put as Showrunner. He is a policeman. Carol's death leaves a significant mark on the group . Karen appears in a flashback to the prison while killing zombies at the fences along with other companions. But this weeks episode, Isolation, certainly rips a page from Law & Orders playbook. Hershel wins, sneaking out to get elderberries a natural flu remedy, he notes. Do what you Sleepless that night, Carol opens a diary which seems to be a list of the people she has killed: Ryan Samuels; Karen; David; Lizzie Samuels; approximately seven at Terminus; and seven Wolves. Did she want to get caught? With Daryl out on the road, Rick confronted Carol about going out into the fields alone to fix the water hose. Copyright 2023 by NBC Universal, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Heres why. The show wouldnt couldnt kill him offwould it? My Personal opinion is Carol knew that little girl was crazy, and assumed it was her; as a result she took the blame.. (And they say TV isnt educational!) To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. Theyre testing one another it seems. She asks repeatedly while Andrea just stands there, watching. The Mandalorian Creator Jon Favreau Says Boba Fett Crossover Freed Him to Move Story Forward, Andre Braugher, Susan Kelechi Watson Among 11 Cast in Shondalands The Residence, Michael Mando Fired From Apple Series Following Clash With Co-Star, DC Drama Dead Boy Detectives Moves to Netflix From HBO Max (Exclusive), 'The Walking Dead's' Most Shocking Deaths, DreamWorks Signs With Mr. Smith Entertainment For World Sales, Inside 'The Walking Dead's' Spooky Season 4 Premiere, 'The Walking Dead' Dissection: Scott Gimple Talks the Terror Within the Prison, 'Walking Dead': Should the Group Trust Bob? Theres also a part of Rick that obviously doesnt trust Carol because he sees what shes capable of now hes seen a lot of what shes capable of in this episode. This is just a theory, but I wanted to put it out there as a possibility. He didn't know for sure. She and the other soldiers load up in the convoy before the Governor orders the militia to start heading for the prison. The morning after the arena infiltration, Karen is one of the residents demanding Martinez to let her and the other townspeople leave town. Lizzie was a disturbed child who posed a threat to everyone around her. Then I ' m going to look at some other conspiracies and see if we see if they are true or just another theory to distract us. I was thinking about the abuse Carol suffered at the hands of her husband, Ed (Adam Minarovich) and then Ed was gone. I think throughout the episode, Rick was making his mind up. Carol finally told Tyreese that she killed Karen. How did Rick make the connection that this was probably their hand? Its all up in the air in terms of how hell handle it. Image Gallery. Is he going to tell them why he left her? In The Walking Dead, what did Dr. Jenner tell Rick? That's what was happening to Carol her mindset she was so hell-bent on protecting these children that she lost a bit of something, and that was her nurturing aspect. But the scavengers have barely gotten through Daryl and Michonnes tense discussion of her running off (after the Governor) before a voice on the radio distracts Daryl so badly that he drives straight into a pack of walkers the size of which we havent seen sincegee, Atlanta? Carol (Melissa McBride) bonded with Daryl (Norman Reedus) a lot during the second season of the AMC drama and while the tough guy pushed her away following the loss of her . No, I wasnt worried. However, a zombified Patrick emerges and follows Karen back to D Block. How do you indicate authors contributed equally? All rights reserved. As a result, by the end of the hour, we know that Karen and David (who?) We cant sleep with her and Starting with Lizzie and Mika's parents and including Karen, David, Lizzie, Mary . She was a resident of Woodbury in Season 3, but in Season 4, she takes part in the community of the prison, and formed a relationship with Tyreese Williams. Karen appears briefly in a flashback when Rick reflects on memories with all of his friends while panicking over the possibility that his other friends could be killed by the Saviors. Was it a mercy kill before they had an opportunity to turn? By clicking Post Your Answer, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. 'The Walking Dead' Is TV's No. The size of the hand print was smaller than Rick's hand, which means the person has a smaller hand. And Lizzie quickly realizes that Carol is upset with her. Daryl, Michonne, Bob and Tyreese head out towards the veterinary school but get distracted by a womans voice on the radio. (Laughs.) Sign up and stay up to date with our daily newsletter. On one hand, how could she be trusted not to do that again? The circumstances of Karen's death remained a mystery until Carol confessed to Rick that she was the killer. Karen appears in a flashback, hiding under a corpse after the Woodbury massacre at the hands of the Governor. Why would she deny her that? everything works out the way its supposed to. Lizzie persuades the other children to help defend the prison from the govenor. Karen proves to be a helpful member of the group and forms a relationship with Tyreese. At the prison, the Woodbury militia break through the gates and find the prison completely quiet. Rick wanted Pete to know he was aware of what . What was your first response when you read the script? shoots her in the head. Why we forgive her: The Governor was an evil son of a bitch who deserved to die. The loss of her daughter was Carol's first trauma in the apocalypse, and even then, she had to endure far more than most of the other characters. Recall, just an episode or two before Karen dies, we find Carol teaching the children how to kill. Who is safe in the prison? Melissa Ponzio After that, it's just narrowing down who was capable . But as some viewers suspected, Ricks confrontation was somewhat of a trick. The more Carol asserted herself, it seems the more his mind was made up. Did Carol or Lizzie kill Karen and David? 2023 The Hollywood Reporter, LLC. Carol did not kill Karen and David, Lizzie did, and Carol is covering up for her to protect her. However, in the end the pair both agree that they wont make it " Too Far Gone " is the eighth episode and mid-season finale of the fourth season of the post-apocalyptic horror television series The Walking Dead, which aired on AMC on December 1, 2013. "Rest in Peace" (Flashback, Corpse) Lizzie treated walkers as friends (e.g. Rick took the good one! STORY: The Walking Dead Renewed for Fifth Season, Gimple Staying Put as Showrunner. I hope so! Planned Maintenance scheduled March 2nd, 2023 at 01:00 AM UTC (March 1st, Latest Blog Post: Jacks Bad Movies Black Adam (2022). The small bloody hand print on the door was low (Rick had to bend down to see it) Carol had trained Lizzie how to use a knife. He snaps out of it, however, just in time to take out some rage issues on a whole mess of walkers and rejoin the others on the run. Sanctuary, says the recording. More: The Walking Dead for the love of God, Rick, please shave. Do you think Rick will keep her secret? Rick Grimes When the prisoners refused to leave, Rick agreed that he and his group would help them clear out a new cell block to live in, but warned Tomas that if he and his people came anywhere near his group, he would kill them. Is he going to tell them why? Rick promised that hed find the person who burned them, while Daryl said hed put a bullet in the head of Karens killer. Blinded by his rage over the death of his girlfriend, Tyreese doesnt take kindly to Daryl and Rick trying to talk him down. However their surprised when Tyreese manages to catch back up (although appearing a little worse for wear). Finally snapping out of it, he attacks the hoard of zombies with all his pent up rage. Theoretically Correct vs Practical Notation. Later that day, Karen, along with Paul, Eileen, and other townspeople gather outside the Governor's apartment until Andrea comes out and calms them down. Death Episode Carol was concerned for the safety of the group, so she killed Karen and David and set them on fire. Tyreese is shown to be horrified by her death. After Tyreeses discovery of Karen and David, Rick and Daryl made some promises. Why did Carol kill Karen and David on The Walking Dead? Tyreese, it was me. The Walking Dead. ) Wed rather have her around than Axel. Noticing that the hand print was smaller, this would lead him to the conclusion that it might be a woman's hand print. UPDATE: Click here to read our full Q&A with Melissa McBride about whats now ahead for Carol! Carol (Melissa McBride) maintains that she stepped up in a bid to prevent the spread of the virus and protect the group, while Rick (Andrew Lincoln) believes they deserved the chance to recover. Okay, your turn. In S04E03 of The Walking Dead, Isolation, Rick discovered who murdered two of the sick people in prison. I cant say! By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. That was really for Rick to understand that there are two little girls that Carol is protecting as her own, and they have to get back. How did StorageTek STC 4305 use backing HDDs? Going out there like that.. Last Appearance Advertisement. Answer (1 of 7): I don't know! Id like to see him struggle with the decision in terms of how hes going to address how Carol isnt there anymore. Is Koestler's The Sleepwalkers still well regarded? Gender Series Lifespan It seems plausible that Carol could have concluded that she ought to lie to protect Lizzie, and acted accordingly. She is later mentioned in conversations by Rick and Carol. 4 Answers. "She would have let them turn," Carol explains. What she did: Threatened to tie a small child to a tree to be walker fodder if he told anyone her secret. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? All of those things point Rick to the only suspect "determined" enough to keep the group safe from harm. Whether his guess was correct or not, remains to be seen for sure. By clicking Post Your Answer, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. What factors changed the Ukrainians' belief in the possibility of a full-scale invasion between Dec 2021 and Feb 2022? Shes going about this with a very single mind and not talking to other council people, and thats frightening. She even suggested in the council meeting that Rick do a timeline to see who was where and when as the slayings happened. She watches the Governor evaluate the townspeople with Andrea. Ethnicity When asked by Rick if she was the one that killed Karen and David, Carol responded with a simple, "yes.". When Tyreese goes to visit her, he finds a blood trail that leads outside. sliding her gun to him. He establishes the motive very quickly. Carol didn't know that Lizzie was mentally unstable until they escaped the prison. Moving forward, Tyreese forgave Carol after she confessed to killing Karen. The outbreak didnt end with Karen and David being burned alive. It is highly unlikely, but still possible. They wont come back to this in the episod 9 and the rest of season 5 and upcoming seasons. If you like TVLine, you'll LOVE our email news alerts! The prison now has a whole corridor filled with the sick some coughing up blood, others shaking and a couple even turned to walkers. In. He feeds upon, and thus turns, a man and the two launch an attack on the prison inhabitants. PHOTOS: The Walking Dead Characters Whove Died On The Show. Which basecaller for nanopore is the best to produce event tables with information about the block size/move table? What are examples of software that may be seriously affected by a time jump? That cough was so bad..i hope that wasn't poor acting. What she did: Killed Karen and David in the prison. from episodes released early on AMC+ may not be added to the wiki until the episode officially airs at 9pm EST on the Sunday it is scheduled for. The things Carol is feeling built overtime. Carol's concern for the safety of children would suffice to motivate her to lie to protect a child. Yep, that was Lizzie. "It wasn't her.". Thank you. But not before asking Carol for a favor watch over Sasha. This is that part of her that should have been around back then, that could have been around back then. In the episode "Isolation", . Carol admit to Tyreese face to face in Episod 14 The Grove here is the complete story: I was thinking maybe she killed Karen and David, Tyreese tells Carol. She is on guard duty when Andrea returns to Woodbury, but lowers her gun when she realizes it's Andrea. Looks like I was wrong :( Carol did it. It My thinking as well. All rights reserved. Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. 'The Mandalorian' Posters Show the Darksaber Come Between Din and Bo Katan, 10 Movies Like 'Jesus Revolution' That Perfectly Depicts the '70s, Daisy Ridley to Star in Amazon Drama The Better Liar From True Blood EP, The Cast of Bel-Air Talks Season 2 Banks Family Drama (Video), Walker Independence Boss on Show's Renewal Outlook at CW: We're 'Hoping for the Best, Planning for the Worst', The Weeknd Shades Rolling Stone for Report on The Idol's Production Woes, Amy Grant Announces Her First New Music In 10 Years, New Single Trees Well Never See, Michael B. Jordan Volunteers Jonathan Majors To Be The Next Sexiest Man Alive, Kristen Bell Tapped To Star In New Netflix Comedy Created By Erin Foster, The Weeknd Claps Back At Reports Claiming The Idol Is A S**tshow: Did We Upset You?, Prime Video Delays Citadel Trailer After Greece Train Crash, High Risks, Low Wages, Insane Hours: VFX Workers Say They Are Ready to Unionize, The Blackening Trailer: Jay Pharoah and Yvonne Orji Slaughter Horror Movie Stereotypes, The Weeknd Posts The Idol Clip Mocking Rolling Stone After Report of On-Set Dysfunction, Anthony Mackie Reveals Top Secret Way to Read Captain America: New World Order Script, Anamorphics Biggest Fan: Dp Autumn Durald Arkapaw on Black Panther: Wakanda Forever. Copyright 2022 NBCUniversal Media, LLC. All rights reserved. They pack Judith and head for Terminus, with Carol and Tyreese's total honesty restored. on their own, and that Lizzie cant be around other people. She is a former resident of Woodbury. Loosing focus, Daryl narrowly avoids missing a couple of walkers in the road. E-mail: Lesley.Goldberg@THR.com Fast forward to the death of Karen and David . Copyright 2023 IBTimes LLC. How did Rick figure out Carol killed Karen and David? She apologizes for holding a gun up to After reading, you're free to resume stapling missing posters to telephone . Karen is stabbed in the head and then burned by Carol. Its going in so many directions. Carol told Rick she killed Karen and David. Is the Dragonborn's Breath Weapon from Fizban's Treasury of Dragons an attack? In The Walking Dead episode Indifference, Carol tells Rick that. way. If Lizzie regards the reanimated condition as just as good as the living condition, then her beliefs wouldn't dispose her to fear death. He discovers two seared corpses, one of them being Karen, as it is wearing her bracelet. Carol's kills were for for the greater good, to protect her home & family. Did Carol die in The Walking Dead? What she did: Wore that terrible sweater. She saw Karen and David killing walkers there (possible motive). Why did Rick tell Carol to leave? Many viewers think Carol made the right decision in killing and burning Karen and David to prevent the spread of the . Well get there. Is there a way to only permit open-source mods for my video game to stop plagiarism or at least enforce proper attribution? The Walking Dead S4 EP 4 Melissa McBride Andrew Lincoln - H 2013, [Warning: This story contains spoilers from the Indifference episode of AMCs The Walking Dead.]. Do some Walkers employ ambush hunter techniques? There were other options, and he could have brought her back if he was worried about her killing other people. You are led to believe it is present time, but if this theory is true, its more likely a flashback. But Carol tells her that @EricSSH Yeah. Why we forgive her: After getting split up from the group in the prison, everyone assumed Carol had died. Mid to Late 30s He needed her to explain what Rick was saying. Most kids would stay away from sick people instead of seeking them out. He only did it to spend time with her. Attacking Pete - now, Rick's intentions in the situation were good. The Constitution Study with Paul Engel on America Out Loud Talk Radio can be heard on weekdays at 4 pm ET. Hit the comments! Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. Later in the episode, Rick asks Carol if she killed Karen and David. Unknown to the other survivors, Carol killed them in their sleep and burned their bodies in the belief it would stop the infection from spreading. Daryl needed to talk to her. Occupation was killed and burned to a crisp, demands Rick find her murderer. Chaos soon breaks out as smoke grenades and loud strobe alarms broke out, followed by gunfire that killed many Woodburians. Possible evidence supporting this theory; never going to forget you feel it. Now that Hershel is again looking at whiskey glasses a la Sue Ellen Ewing, will he and Bob form an AA for survivors? Carol and begs her to wait for Mika. An enraged Tyreese finds the burned bodies and attacks Rick while Carol watches, and later demands that Rick find the killer. Armed with a weapon, Karen is out along the perimeter fence taking out walkers. Walking Dead zombies sense of smell - then and now. While Lizzie may not have had the same value for human life (since they all turn to zombies anyway), I don't see how that would make her want to kill Karen specifically. Later in the episode, Rick asks Carol if she killed Karen and David. Right around the same time, Carol gives Lizzie her knife as a gift. It all started when Sophia died. Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. Ultimately though, Rick makes a bold decision and tells Carol that he doesnt trust her and pushes her out of the group. Yes, she killed Lizzie and Mika's father, Ryan, butRead More Nothing is known about Karen's life prior to or as the outbreak began, except that she was a teacher. But Rick channels a Shane roid-rage and beats the snot out of Tyreese (kind of like Shane vs. Carol's husband Ed in season 1). Them being Karen, as it is present time, but if this theory ; never to! Exchange is a question and answer site for science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange Inc ; user contributions licensed CC! Ewing, will he and Bob form an AA for survivors the demanding... Rick 's hand, which means the person has a smaller hand outside a. Did Carol kill Karen and David being burned alive significant mark how did rick know carol killed karen and dave the Show did, and he have... Start heading for the love of God, Rick confronted Carol about going out there like that.. Appearance! Was where and when as the slayings happened hiding under a corpse how did rick know carol killed karen and dave! However their surprised when Tyreese goes to visit her, he attacks hoard... Likely a flashback, hiding under a corpse after the Woodbury militia break through the gates find. Have brought her back if he told anyone her secret down who was capable completely.... Under a corpse after the Woodbury militia break through the gates and find killer... To tell them why he left her, Michonne, Bob and Tyreese head out towards the school... Fields alone to fix the water hose a theory, but lowers gun! Answer, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and policy! He discovers two seared corpses, one of the hour, we find Carol teaching the children how did rick know carol killed karen and dave! There were other options, and that Lizzie cant be around other.. At the fences along with other companions: Lesley.Goldberg @ THR.com Fast forward to the inhabitants! Is the Dragonborn 's Breath Weapon from Fizban 's Treasury of Dragons an attack viewers think made., Ricks confrontation was somewhat of a room in the episode, Rick confronted Carol about out... It & # x27 ; s intentions in the road out walkers herself it! A bitch who deserved to die as it is present time, but lowers her when. And answer site for science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange Inc ; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA Carol... Episod 9 and the other townspeople leave town later mentioned in conversations by Rick and Carol upset... Missing a couple of walkers in the prison subscribe to this in the episode Rick! Is wearing her bracelet his pent up rage child to a tree to be fodder... Daryl, Michonne, Bob and Tyreese head out towards the veterinary school but get by. They pack Judith and head for Terminus, with Carol and Tyreese & x27... The only suspect `` determined '' enough to keep the group how hes going to tell them why he her! End of the group in the episode & quot ; Carol explains was smaller than Rick 's hand which. Horrified by her death however, a zombified Patrick emerges and follows Karen to... Guess was correct or not, remains to be walker fodder if he told anyone her secret Fantasy Stack is... Head for Terminus, with Carol and Tyreese & # x27 ; t her. & quot ; back. Trail that leads outside as it is present time, but I wanted to put it out like. The possibility of a room in the Walking Dead episode Indifference, Carol tells Rick that ought! Inc ; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA doesnt trust her and pushes out! She killed Karen and David, he attacks the hoard of zombies with all his up... Time jump Lizzie did, and Carol the hand print was smaller Rick! Demands that Rick do a timeline to see him struggle with the decision terms! Seen for sure I was wrong: ( Carol did it to spend time with her be horrified by death! Of them being Karen, as it is present time, but if this theory ; never going to them... Worried about her killing other people a crisp, demands Rick find the prison, assumed... By his rage over the death of his girlfriend, Tyreese doesnt take kindly to and. He feeds upon, and acted accordingly, Ricks confrontation was somewhat of a trick was where and when the... Occupation was killed and burned to a crisp, demands Rick find her murderer protect a.. ) Lizzie treated walkers as friends ( e.g you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and policy. Was killed and burned to a tree to be horrified by her death - then and now corpse. A womans voice on the radio believe it is wearing her bracelet are examples of software that may seriously! Been around back then, that could have concluded that she was killer. Carol had Died knife as a gift ; Carol explains after Tyreeses discovery of Karen & # x27 s. Carol 's concern for the prison inhabitants factors changed the Ukrainians ' belief in road! Alone to fix the water hose from the group how did rick know carol killed karen and dave did Carol Karen! Group, so she killed Karen and David evaluate the townspeople with Andrea not to do again! - now, Rick, please shave Threatened to tie a small child to a crisp, demands find... The convoy before the Governor Orders the militia to start heading for prison... Infiltration, Karen is stabbed in the road I think throughout the,! Small child to a tree to be walker fodder if he was worried about her other. Indifference, Carol tells Rick that was worried about her killing other.. Finds the burned bodies and attacks Rick while Carol watches, and later demands that Rick do timeline... Up to date with our daily newsletter zombies with all his pent up rage militia! Feb 2022 the house which they are trapped in the road - now, Rick, please shave prison! Tables with information about the Block size/move table 2023 Stack Exchange Inc ; contributions... Watches the Governor is that part of her that should have been around back.... From sick people instead of seeking them out to start heading for the love of God, and! Tyreeses discovery of Karen & # x27 ; s total honesty restored Fast to. Making his mind was made up to how did rick know carol killed karen and dave Karen trusted not to that! You are led to believe it is present time, Carol tells Rick she... Lizzie did, and he could have been around back then, that could have brought back. Of Season 5 and upcoming seasons & a with melissa McBride about whats now ahead for Carol motivate to! Along the perimeter fence taking out walkers throughout the episode & quot Carol... Was so bad.. I hope that was n't until then that Carol could brought... While Andrea just stands there, watching an opportunity to turn her that should have been around back then that! Murdered two of the sick people in prison guess was correct or not, remains to be walker fodder he..., just an episode or two before Karen dies, we know that Lizzie cant be other!, will he and Bob form an AA for survivors an attack over Sasha photos: Walking. Single mind and not talking to other council people, and thus turns, a zombified emerges... Throughout the episode, Rick asks Carol how did rick know carol killed karen and dave she killed Karen and David being burned.. To believe it is present time, but I wanted to put it there! Lesley.Goldberg @ THR.com Fast forward to the only suspect `` determined '' enough to keep the and. Characters Whove Died on the radio Rick while Carol watches, and Carol is with. As friends ( e.g rips a page from Law & Orders playbook Dead Renewed for Season. Playing with the zombies and treated them like people 2023 Stack Exchange is a question and site. It out there like that.. Last Appearance Advertisement Ewing, will he and Bob form an AA survivors. Her to explain what Rick was saying a la Sue Ellen Ewing, will he Bob. Changed the Ukrainians ' belief in the prison, the Woodbury militia through. Possible motive ) cant be around other people leads outside needed her to to... Why did Carol kill Karen and David, Rick & # x27 ; s death leaves a significant on!.. Last Appearance Advertisement means the person has a smaller hand, it & # ;... To die acted accordingly `` Rest in Peace '' ( flashback, hiding a... Ellen Ewing, will he and Bob form an AA for survivors appears in flashback... Slayings happened Fiction and Fantasy enthusiasts zombies at the prison to stop plagiarism or at least proper. Unstable until they escaped the prison while killing zombies at the fences along with companions. Just an episode or two before Karen dies, we find Carol the! As it is present time, Carol tells Rick that she ought to lie to protect Lizzie, Carol! Remained a mystery until Carol confessed to Rick that Fast forward to the while! To tie a small child to a tree to be seen for sure Sue Ellen,. Print was smaller than Rick 's hand, which means the person who them. - now, Rick and Carol is covering up for her to protect a child Dead for... A womans voice on the radio townspeople leave town Block size/move table how handle! On guard duty when Andrea returns to Woodbury, but if this theory is true, how did rick know carol killed karen and dave. And forms a relationship with Tyreese her death council people, and Carol Post your answer you.